ever seen one of these videos?
INT. a bearded white man with round glasses in a sweater (unsubtle professor cosplay) is seated at a desk in a blinding white void
he adjusts his performative stack of notes (blank sheets of copy paper) to indicate that he has researched this topic far more thoroughly than you
phew guys, this <current event> is really complicated, and widdle tiny babies like you have absolutely no hope of understanding it without the majestic guiding hand of journalism. vox and vice used to have the responsibility of delivering you patronizing explainers in the 2010s but it turns out putting a bunch of salaried millennials in an air conditioned office in manhattan to deliver news to the only demographic that knows how to use adblockers is an economic dead-end. we all got fired and replaced with untalented zoomers (theyre so desperate for a media job theyre willing to work as nonunion contractors!) so now im an independent journalistic voice coming to you from my bootstrapped film studio! (please do not google newpress)
soft marimba music starts playing. your iq increases 15 points upon hearing it
so basically, you complete idiot, you buffoon, you brainless sucker, whats going on with <current event> is <offensively reductive analysis that paints an entirely confused and misleading narrative about large macro events somehow primarily stemming from a small handful of legible causes>
incredibly well composed photos from the AP and Reuters flicker across the screen too fast for you to appreciate them, overstimulating your optical nerves so hard that you healthy gell-mann skepticism simply vaporizes
heres a lot of visual aids that ive taped up onto my tackboard in a well structured table (i understand that youre supposed to tack things to a tackboard but tacks dont show up well on camera ok?) and yeah you cant see the graphic/chart because its too small/i flicked it past the camera in a barrage of charts with a cool little clicky sound effect to make you feel a powerful gestalt, but thats ok, all that really matters is that it lends this pure narrative—delivered without citation or even really anything you could call argumentation—major academic vibes that really pump up my credibility store.

the man in this screenshot is in the middle of saying, i kid you not, word for word: “I know you can’t see the little faces and names, that’s fine. What I want you to notice is…
hey! you! pay attention! were you just about to click off? is it because i spoke three sentences in a row without cutting away to a two second clip from a legacy news broadcast? thats my bad. how about 12 two second clips in a row, all repeating the exact same thing over and over again so you dont miss the extremely basic point im trying to make? you dullard, you fool, you knave.
END SCENE
i know this is a hypocritical amount of snark coming from me given my position on being a hater but i need you to grant me an exception here because goodness gracious do these explainer videos make my blood boil. my least generous interpretation of them is that they are delivered in such a patronizing and lowbrow manner so as to flatter their audience. if they can make the topic out to be hopelessly complicated and then deliver a slick and digestible narrative then the avg audience member walks away feeling affirmed in their own intelligence and grasp of the situation. its milquetoast slopulist commentary for the dunning-kruger class. as anyone who has taken a genuinely difficult course can attest: quality edifying education feels like it elevates both your understanding and your confusion about the topic with each new revelation. it raises as many questions as it answers. these videos do not exist to expand your knowledge of the world, they exist to make you feel warm and fuzzy inside (and of course to entertain you so you obediently sit through the sponsored segment). i do not feel flattered. for me it drips with the host’s contempt and mistrust of my ability to apprehend the world without the safety of a prechewed narrative.
its the epistemic bankruptcy and algomaxxing of iflscience but about current events (but also sometimes about science as well). and best of all, legacy media is catching up to it, even the papers of record got their zoomer contractors doing the 60-second white void explainers. what are you gonna do about it, read a book? yeah thats what i thought bonehead.